07 Mar, 2023

Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

Vulnerability Assessment as a Service (VAaaS)

Tests systems and applications for vulnerabilities to address weaknesses.

Insufficient Session Fixation Protection (ISFP) refers to a vulnerability in web applications where the session IDs used to authenticate a user’s session are not properly protected from malicious actors. This can occur when a web application fails to regenerate the session ID after a user logs in, or when it allows session IDs to be passed as part of a URL parameter. Attackers can exploit this vulnerability to hijack a user’s session and gain unauthorized access to sensitive information or perform actions on behalf of the victim.

Example of vulnerable code on different programming languages:


in PHP:

				
					<?php
session_start();
if(isset($_SESSION['authenticated']) && $_SESSION['authenticated'] == true) {
   header('Location: secure_page.php');
   exit;
}

if(isset($_POST['username']) && isset($_POST['password'])) {
   // Code to authenticate user credentials
   $_SESSION['authenticated'] = true;
   $_SESSION['username'] = $_POST['username'];
   header('Location: secure_page.php');
   exit;
}
?>

				
			


In this PHP example, the session ID is not regenerated after the user logs in. An attacker can hijack the session by obtaining the session ID before the user logs in, and then using it to access the secure page after the user logs in.

• in Java:

				
					HttpSession session = request.getSession(true);
session.setAttribute("authenticated", true);
session.setAttribute("username", request.getParameter("username"));
response.sendRedirect("secure_page.jsp");

				
			


In this Java example, the session ID is not regenerated after the user logs in. An attacker can hijack the session by obtaining the session ID before the user logs in, and then using it to access the secure page after the user logs in.

• in Python:

				
					@app.route('/login', methods=['POST'])
def login():
   username = request.form['username']
   password = request.form['password']
   # Code to authenticate user credentials
   session['authenticated'] = True
   session['username'] = username
   return redirect('/secure_page')

				
			


In this Python example, the session ID is not regenerated after the user logs in. An attacker can hijack the session by obtaining the session ID before the user logs in, and then using it to access the secure page after the user logs in.

Examples of exploitation Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

Session hijacking:

An attacker can obtain the victim’s session ID through various means, such as sniffing network traffic, stealing cookies, or social engineering attacks. If the application does not regenerate the session ID after login, the attacker can use the obtained session ID to access the victim’s account and perform actions on their behalf.

Session fixation:

An attacker can force a victim to use a specific session ID by tricking them into clicking on a malicious link that includes the session ID. If the application does not regenerate the session ID after login, the attacker can use the fixed session ID to access the victim’s account and perform actions on their behalf.

Session prediction:

An attacker can predict a valid session ID by analyzing the pattern of session IDs generated by the application. If the application does not regenerate the session ID after login, the attacker can use the predicted session ID to access the victim’s account and perform actions on their behalf.

Session replay:

An attacker can capture a valid session ID and replay it to access the victim’s account. If the application does not regenerate the session ID after login, the attacker can use the replayed session ID to access the victim’s account and perform actions on their behalf.

Privilege escalation techniques for Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

Session ID brute-forcing:

If the session ID is not sufficiently long or complex, an attacker can use brute-force techniques to guess valid session IDs and escalate privileges to gain access to additional functionality or sensitive information.

Session fixation combined with cross-site scripting (XSS):

An attacker can use a cross-site scripting vulnerability to inject a malicious script into the victim’s browser that sets a fixed session ID. If the victim logs in while the malicious script is active, the attacker can use the fixed session ID to gain access to the victim’s account.

Session hijacking combined with a targeted attack:

An attacker can use the hijacked session to gain access to the victim’s account and perform reconnaissance to identify additional vulnerabilities or sensitive information. They can then use this information to launch a more targeted attack, such as exploiting a privilege escalation vulnerability or stealing sensitive data.

Session replay combined with a CSRF attack:

An attacker can capture a valid session ID and use it to perform actions on the victim’s behalf using a CSRF attack. This can escalate privileges by allowing the attacker to perform actions that the victim would not normally have permission to perform.

General methodology and checklist for Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

Methodology:

  1. Identify the target web application: Determine the scope of the test and identify the specific web application or applications that will be tested.

  2. Map the application: Use a web application mapping tool to discover and identify all of the application’s pages and functionality.

  3. Identify authentication mechanisms: Determine how the application handles authentication and session management.

  4. Identify session ID generation and management: Determine how the application generates and manages session IDs.

  5. Check for session fixation: Attempt to fix a session ID and see if the application accepts it after the user logs in.

  6. Check for session prediction: Analyze the session ID generation algorithm to see if it is predictable and can be easily guessed.

  7. Check for session replay: Capture a valid session ID and see if it can be replayed to gain unauthorized access.

  8. Attempt to hijack a session: Use a network sniffing tool or other method to intercept a user’s session ID and see if it can be used to gain unauthorized access.

  9. Attempt privilege escalation: Once access has been gained to a user’s account, attempt to escalate privileges using known vulnerabilities or other techniques.

  10. Document and report findings: Document all findings and report them to the appropriate parties, including a detailed description of the vulnerability, its impact, and recommended remediation steps.

Checklist:

  1. Verify that the application generates a new session ID for each user upon login.

  2. Check if the application uses SSL/TLS to encrypt the session ID during transmission.

  3. Verify that the session ID is invalidated after logout or session timeout.

  4. Check if the application enforces the use of HTTPS protocol for all sensitive pages and actions.

  5. Check if the application uses random and long enough session IDs to make them difficult to guess.

  6. Verify that the application does not include the session ID in the URL or other easily accessible locations.

  7. Check if the application re-generates the session ID when a user’s privilege level changes.

  8. Verify that the application does not allow for session fixation by testing if a fixed session ID is accepted after a user logs in.

  9. Check if the application uses secure session management mechanisms such as HTTP-only and secure flags in session cookies.

  10. Verify that the application implements proper input validation and access control mechanisms to prevent session hijacking and other attacks.

  11. Check if the application logs all session-related events, including login and logout, session creation and destruction, and changes to session state.

  12. Verify that the application undergoes regular security testing and auditing to detect and remediate any vulnerabilities.

Tools set for exploiting Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

Manual Tools:

  • Burp Suite: A popular web application testing platform that includes a proxy, scanner, and other tools for manual testing. It can be used to intercept and modify session ID values and perform other session-related attacks.

  • Tamper Data: A Firefox plugin that allows manual interception and modification of HTTP requests and responses. It can be used to modify session ID values and test for session fixation vulnerabilities.

  • Wireshark: A network protocol analyzer that can be used to capture and analyze network traffic. It can be used to capture session IDs and other sensitive data during testing.

  • Fiddler: A proxy server that allows manual interception and modification of HTTP traffic. It can be used to modify session ID values and test for session fixation vulnerabilities.

  • ZAP: An open-source web application scanner that includes a proxy and other tools for manual testing. It can be used to identify and exploit session-related vulnerabilities.

  • Hydra: A command-line tool for brute-forcing login credentials and session IDs. It can be used to test for weak session ID values.

  • Firebug: A browser extension for Firefox that allows manual inspection and modification of HTML, CSS, and JavaScript. It can be used to modify session ID values and test for session fixation vulnerabilities.

  • Nmap: A network exploration and security auditing tool that can be used to scan for open ports and services. It can be used to identify web applications and other targets for testing.

Automated Tools:

  • OWASP Zed Attack Proxy (ZAP): An open-source web application scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • Acunetix: A commercial web application scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • Nessus: A commercial vulnerability scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • Qualys: A cloud-based vulnerability management platform that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • Nikto: An open-source web server scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • OpenVAS: An open-source vulnerability scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • Arachni: An open-source web application scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • Skipfish: An open-source web application scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • AppSpider: A commercial web application scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • WebInspect: A commercial web application scanner that includes automated testing for session-related vulnerabilities.

Browser Plugins:

  • Cookie Cadger: A plugin for intercepting and analyzing cookies. It can be used to test for session-related vulnerabilities.

  • EditThisCookie: A plugin for modifying cookies. It can be used to modify session ID values and test for session fixation vulnerabilities.

Average CVSS score of stack Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

The CVSS score for Insufficient Session Fixation Protection vulnerability can vary based on the severity of the vulnerability and the impact it can have on the system or application.

The CVSS score ranges from 0 to 10 and is based on several factors, including the impact on confidentiality, integrity, and availability, as well as the ease of exploitability and the required user privileges.

On average, Insufficient Session Fixation Protection vulnerabilities are classified as moderate to high severity, with a CVSS score ranging from 4.0 to 8.0. However, the actual score can vary depending on the specifics of the vulnerability and the affected system or application.

The Common Weakness Enumeration (CWE)

• CWE-384: Session Fixation: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to hijack a user’s session by fixing the session ID value, either by predicting the value or by forcing the user to use a specific session ID.

• CWE-613: Insufficient Session Expiration: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to use a previously valid session ID to gain access to the application after the session has ended.

• CWE-614: Sensitive Cookie in HTTPS Session Without ‘Secure’ Attribute: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to intercept sensitive cookies in an HTTPS session if the ‘secure’ attribute is not set.

• CWE-522: Insufficiently Protected Credentials: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to steal credentials, such as session IDs or authentication tokens, by intercepting network traffic or using other methods to extract sensitive information.

• CWE-525: Information Exposure Through Browser Cache: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to obtain sensitive information, such as session IDs, by viewing the browser’s cache.

• CWE-799: Improper Control of Interaction Frequency: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to perform actions on behalf of a user, such as changing their password or modifying their account information, by abusing session-related functionality.

• CWE-807: Reliance on Untrusted Inputs in a Security Decision: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to manipulate session-related data, such as the session ID, to bypass security controls and gain unauthorized access.

• CWE-814: Incomplete Blacklist: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to inject malicious data, such as session IDs or other sensitive information, by exploiting a weakness in a blacklist or filter.

• CWE-918: Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF): A vulnerability that allows an attacker to manipulate session-related data by making unauthorized requests to a server, typically by exploiting weaknesses in server-side functionality.

• CWE-933: Unsafe Reflection: A vulnerability that allows an attacker to manipulate session-related data, such as the session ID, by exploiting weaknesses in reflection-based functionality.

Top 10 CVES related to Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

• CVE-2022-24895 – Symfony is a PHP framework for web and console applications and a set of reusable PHP components. When authenticating users Symfony by default regenerates the session ID upon login, but preserves the rest of session attributes. Because this does not clear CSRF tokens upon login, this might enables same-site attackers to bypass the CSRF protection mechanism by performing an attack similar to a session-fixation. This issue has been fixed in the 4.4 branch.

• CVE-2022-20752 – A vulnerability in Cisco Unified Communications Manager (Unified CM), Cisco Unified Communications Manager Session Management Edition (Unified CM SME), and Cisco Unity Connection could allow an unauthenticated, remote attacker to perform a timing attack. This vulnerability is due to insufficient protection of a system password. An attacker could exploit this vulnerability by observing the time it takes the system to respond to various queries. A successful exploit could allow the attacker to determine a sensitive system password.

• CVE-2021-46279 – Session fixation and insufficient session expiration vulnerabilities allow an attacker to perfom session hijacking attacks against users. This issue affects: Lanner Inc IAC-AST2500A standard firmware version 1.10.0.

• CVE-2021-35948 – Session fixation on password protected public links in the ownCloud Server before 10.8.0 allows an attacker to bypass the password protection when they can force a target client to use a controlled cookie.

• CVE-2020-1673 – Insufficient Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) protection in Juniper Networks J-Web and web based (HTTP/HTTPS) services allows an unauthenticated attacker to hijack the target user’s HTTP/HTTPS session and perform administrative actions on the Junos device as the targeted user. This issue only affects Juniper Networks Junos OS devices with HTTP/HTTPS services enabled such as J-Web, Web Authentication, Dynamic-VPN (DVPN), Firewall Authentication Pass-Through with Web-Redirect, and Zero Touch Provisioning (ZTP). Junos OS devices with HTTP/HTTPS services disabled are not affected.

• CVE-2020-1607 – Insufficient Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) protection in J-Web may potentially allow a remote attacker to inject web script or HTML, hijack the target user’s J-Web session and perform administrative actions on the Junos device as the targeted user. This issue affects Juniper Networks Junos OS 12.3 versions prior to 12.3R12-S15; 12.3X48 versions prior to 12.3X48-D86, 12.3X48-D90 on SRX Series;

• CVE-2019-10158 – A flaw was found in Infinispan through version 9.4.14.Final. An improper implementation of the session fixation protection in the Spring Session integration can result in incorrect session handling.

• CVE-2018-4847 – A vulnerability has been identified in SIMATIC WinCC OA Operator iOS App (All versions < V1.4). Insufficient protection of sensitive information (e.g. session key for accessing server) in Siemens WinCC OA Operator iOS app could allow an attacker with physical access to the mobile device to read unencrypted data from the app’s directory. Siemens provides mitigations to resolve the security issue.

• CVE-2018-1148 – In Nessus before 7.1.0, Session Fixation exists due to insufficient session management within the application. An authenticated attacker could maintain system access due to session fixation after a user password change.

• CVE-2017-3808 – A vulnerability in the Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) UDP throttling process of Cisco Unified Communications Manager (Cisco Unified CM) could allow an unauthenticated, remote attacker to cause a denial of service (DoS) condition on an affected device. The vulnerability is due to insufficient rate limiting protection. An attacker could exploit this vulnerability by sending the affected device a high rate of SIP messages. An exploit could allow the attacker to cause the device to reload unexpectedly. The device and services will restart automatically. This vulnerability affects Cisco Unified Communications Manager (CallManager) releases prior to the first fixed release; the following list indicates the first minor release that includes the fix for this vulnerability: 10.5.2.14900-16 11.0.1.23900-5 11.5.1.12900-2. Cisco Bug IDs: CSCuz72455.

Insufficient Session Fixation Protection exploits

  1. Session fixation: This exploit involves an attacker fixing the session ID value, either by predicting the value or by forcing the user to use a specific session ID, in order to hijack a user’s session.

  2. Session replay: This exploit involves an attacker capturing and replaying a session ID, which allows them to impersonate the original user and gain unauthorized access to the application.

  3. Session hijacking: This exploit involves an attacker stealing a user’s session ID, typically by intercepting network traffic, and using it to gain unauthorized access to the application.

  4. Session injection: This exploit involves an attacker injecting malicious data, such as a session ID or other sensitive information, into the application’s session management functionality in order to gain unauthorized access.

  5. Cross-site request forgery (CSRF): This exploit involves an attacker tricking a user into performing an unintended action, typically by leveraging a session ID or other session-related data to bypass security controls and execute unauthorized requests.

  6. Clickjacking: This exploit involves an attacker hiding a malicious link or button on a legitimate page in order to trick the user into clicking on it and executing an unintended action, such as modifying their session information.

  7. Cookie manipulation: This exploit involves an attacker modifying the values of cookies, typically by intercepting network traffic or exploiting other weaknesses in the application’s session management functionality.

  8. Man-in-the-middle (MitM) attacks: This exploit involves an attacker intercepting network traffic between the user and the application server, typically by exploiting weaknesses in network security protocols, and using this access to manipulate session-related data and gain unauthorized access.

  9. Session fixation via cross-site scripting (XSS): This exploit involves an attacker injecting malicious code, typically via an XSS vulnerability, that forces the user’s browser to use a fixed session ID value chosen by the attacker.

  10. Session fixation via phishing: This exploit involves an attacker tricking the user into logging in to a fake website that sets a fixed session ID value chosen by the attacker, which can then be used to gain unauthorized access to the real website.

Practicing in test for Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

  1. Understand the basics of session management and common vulnerabilities related to session fixation.

  2. Use manual testing techniques, such as intercepting and manipulating network traffic, to identify vulnerabilities related to session management in the application.

  3. Use automated vulnerability scanners, such as OWASP ZAP or Burp Suite, to identify potential vulnerabilities related to session management.

  4. Use tools, such as Firebug or Chrome Developer Tools, to inspect and manipulate cookies and session data in the browser.

  5. Practice exploiting session management vulnerabilities in a controlled environment, such as a test or development environment, to gain a better understanding of how attackers might exploit these vulnerabilities.

  6. Stay up-to-date with the latest security trends and best practices related to session management and other security topics.

  7. Use frameworks and libraries that have built-in security features for session management, such as Spring Security or Django, to minimize the risk of vulnerabilities related to session management.

  8. Test the application thoroughly for other types of vulnerabilities, such as cross-site scripting (XSS), cross-site request forgery (CSRF), and injection vulnerabilities, that can also impact session management.

  9. Implement best practices for session management, such as using random session IDs, expiring sessions after a reasonable time period, and using HTTPS to encrypt session data.

  10. Conduct regular security assessments and penetration testing to identify and address vulnerabilities related to session management and other security issues.

For study Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

Familiarize yourself with the basics of session management and common vulnerabilities related to session fixation. You can start by reading the OWASP Session Management Cheat Sheet.

Review the OWASP Top Ten list and other resources related to web application security to get a broader understanding of common security issues in web applications.

Read technical articles and documentation related to session management and related vulnerabilities, such as session replay, session hijacking, and cross-site request forgery (CSRF).

Practice testing for Insufficient Session Fixation Protection using manual techniques, such as intercepting and manipulating network traffic, and automated vulnerability scanners, such as OWASP ZAP or Burp Suite.

Use tools, such as Firebug or Chrome Developer Tools, to inspect and manipulate cookies and session data in the browser.

Study real-world examples of attacks that leverage Insufficient Session Fixation Protection and related vulnerabilities, and how these attacks were carried out.

Familiarize yourself with security best practices related to session management, such as using random session IDs, expiring sessions after a reasonable time period, and using HTTPS to encrypt session data.

Review the code of open source web applications to identify common mistakes related to session management, and learn how to fix these issues.

Take online courses or attend workshops related to web application security and session management.

Participate in Capture the Flag (CTF) events or bug bounty programs to practice identifying and exploiting vulnerabilities related to session management and other security issues in real-world applications.

Books with review of Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

Web Application Security: A Beginner’s Guide by Bryan Sullivan and Vincent Liu – This book provides an introduction to web application security, including common vulnerabilities like Insufficient Session Fixation Protection, and techniques for securing web applications.

The Web Application Hacker’s Handbook: Finding and Exploiting Security Flaws by Dafydd Stuttard and Marcus Pinto – This book is a comprehensive guide to web application security testing, including advanced techniques for identifying and exploiting vulnerabilities like Insufficient Session Fixation Protection.

Web Security Testing Cookbook: Identify Vulnerabilities and Improve Your Security by Paco Hope and Ben Walther – This book provides practical recipes for testing web application security, including techniques for identifying and testing for Insufficient Session Fixation Protection.

Mastering Modern Web Penetration Testing: Secure Your Modern Web Application from the Ground Up by Prakhar Prasad – This book is a comprehensive guide to web application penetration testing, including advanced techniques for identifying and exploiting vulnerabilities like Insufficient Session Fixation Protection.

Real-World Bug Hunting: A Field Guide to Web Hacking by Peter Yaworski – This book provides real-world examples of web application vulnerabilities, including Insufficient Session Fixation Protection, and techniques for finding and exploiting them.

Web Application Security: Iberic Web Application Security Conference edited by Eduardo Casas and Eduardo Bringas – This book is a collection of papers presented at the Iberic Web Application Security Conference, including papers related to session management and related vulnerabilities.

Web Application Security: A Comprehensive Guide to Securing Your Application in the Cloud by Tom Canavan – This book provides a comprehensive guide to web application security in the cloud, including techniques for identifying and addressing vulnerabilities related to session management.

Web Security: A White Hat Perspective by Markus Schumacher – This book provides an overview of web security, including common vulnerabilities like Insufficient Session Fixation Protection, and techniques for securing web applications.

Learning Nessus for Penetration Testing: Master how to perform IT infrastructure security vulnerability assessments using Nessus with tips and insights from real-world challenges faced during vulnerability scanning by Himanshu Kumar – This book focuses on using Nessus, an automated vulnerability scanner, to identify vulnerabilities in web applications, including vulnerabilities related to session management.

Web Security, Privacy & Commerce by Simson Garfinkel, Gene Spafford, and Alan Schwartz – This book provides an overview of web security, privacy, and commerce, including techniques for identifying and addressing vulnerabilities related to session management.

List of payloads Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

  • Setting a session ID as a parameter in a URL, and then tricking the victim into clicking on the link to the page containing that URL.

  • Manipulating a session ID in a cookie to see if the application accepts it as valid.

  • Forcing the application to generate a new session ID, and then trying to use the old session ID to see if it is still valid.

  • Replaying a captured session ID to see if the application accepts it as valid.

  • Sending the session ID as a hidden field in a form, and then submitting the form to see if the application accepts it as valid.

  • Intercepting and modifying a valid session ID to see if the application accepts the modified ID as valid.

  • Using a brute force attack to guess valid session IDs.

  • Creating multiple concurrent sessions with different session IDs and checking if the application properly isolates the sessions.

  • Using a cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerability to steal a valid session ID from another user.

  • Changing the session ID to that of a user with higher privileges to see if the application allows access to the higher privileges.

How to be protected from Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

  1. Use a strong and cryptographically secure method of generating session IDs.

  2. Set session IDs to be regenerated after a user logs in or changes credentials.

  3. Ensure that session IDs are only transmitted over secure connections (HTTPS) and not over unencrypted connections (HTTP).

  4. Use session timeouts to automatically log users out after a certain period of inactivity.

  5. Implement strict validation of session IDs to prevent tampering or manipulation.

  6. Use cookie flags such as Secure, HttpOnly, and SameSite to prevent session ID theft via XSS attacks or CSRF attacks.

  7. Consider implementing multi-factor authentication to add an extra layer of security to user sessions.

  8. Regularly audit your code for vulnerabilities related to session management, including Insufficient Session Fixation Protection.

  9. Keep your web application up-to-date with the latest security patches and updates.

  10. Educate your developers and users on the risks of Insufficient Session Fixation Protection and how to protect against it.

Mitigations for Insufficient Session Fixation Protection

  1. Implement a secure session management strategy that generates strong and unpredictable session IDs.

  2. Set the session cookie to be secure, HttpOnly, and SameSite, which can prevent session hijacking.

  3. Enforce session timeouts to automatically log out users after a certain period of inactivity.

  4. Implement reauthentication when sensitive operations are performed or the user changes their password.

  5. Use HTTPS to encrypt all traffic between the user and the server to prevent man-in-the-middle attacks.

  6. Consider using multi-factor authentication to add an additional layer of security to user sessions.

  7. Regularly perform vulnerability assessments and penetration testing to identify and address any session management issues.

  8. Educate developers on secure coding practices and how to implement secure session management.

  9. Train users on how to protect their sessions, including logging out of public computers and using strong passwords.

  10. Implement web application firewalls (WAFs) to detect and prevent attacks related to session management, including Insufficient Session Fixation Protection.

Conclusion

Insufficient Session Fixation Protection is a serious vulnerability that can lead to the hijacking of user sessions and the compromise of sensitive information. This vulnerability occurs when an application fails to properly manage session IDs, allowing attackers to hijack a valid user session by predicting or manipulating the session ID.

To protect against Insufficient Session Fixation Protection, it is important to implement secure session management strategies, including the generation of strong and unpredictable session IDs, setting secure cookies, enforcing session timeouts, and using HTTPS to encrypt all traffic between the user and the server.

Regularly auditing and testing for vulnerabilities related to session management can also help identify and mitigate any potential risks. Additionally, educating developers and users on secure coding and session management practices can help prevent this vulnerability from being exploited.

Overall, it is crucial to address Insufficient Session Fixation Protection to ensure the security and privacy of user sessions and to prevent unauthorized access to sensitive information.

Other Services

Ready to secure?

Let's get in touch